Choice not control: Why limiting the fertility of poor populations will not solve the climate crisis

This briefing paper argues that strengthening women’s and girls’ reproductive rights is a global imperative for equitable development, but it must be a priority in its own right, regardless of a country’s population growth and carbon footprint.

The paper is intended as a response to an emerging chorus of voices – predominantly from industrialised countries – which claim that controlling the fertility of people living in poverty should be a strategy of choice to address climate change. The paper argues that increasing women’s access to family planning information and services has to be done out of concern for women’s and girls’ reproductive rights and choices alone, regardless of how fast or slowly a country’s population is growing, and regardless of the volume of greenhouse gases a country is pumping into the atmosphere.

It is human consumption, fundamentally controlled and driven by the world’s elites, and leading to unprecedented levels of global warming and climatic change, rather than large families living in poor countries, that is putting the survival of our ecosystems and all of humanity at greatest risk.

  • Countries: Global
  • Published: December 2014

Related Publications

Suffering in silence: The 10 most under-reported humanitarian crises of 2017

The year 2017 was marked by scores of humanitarian crises: armed conflicts, natural disasters, climate shocks, hunger, displacement. While most of these crises made the headlines, there are others which barely made the news. And when crises are... Read more...

The Path to 2020: Delivering transformative, rights-based family planning

In 2012, CARE joined other civil society organisations, governments and donors to commit to providing an additional 120 million women and girls with family planning information and services by 2020. This report reviews CARE's progress towards our... Read more...

2017 Family Planning Summit: CARE's Key Messages and Policy Asks

FP2020 has brought a powerful focus on family planning – but we must accelerate progress and fill key gaps to ensure we reach all people with the contraception/family planning services they want and... Read more...

Ensuring universal access to family planning in crisis-affected settings: Key messages and policy asks

Of the 225 million women with unmet need for family planning, many live in areas affected by conflict or natural disasters. Delivering family planning services in these settings is critical to ensuring countries meet their FP2020 goals, as well... Read more...

Financial services for resilience: how to assess the impacts?

Implementing innovative methodologies to measure resilience in Niger

This report from the BRACED programme, which aims to build the resilience of vulnerable people against climate extremes and disasters, explores the... Read more...

Land, agriculture and sustainable food systems

An impact learning brief from CARE International in Tanzania

This paper describes learning and evidence from CARE's work in Tanzania to support sustainable, productive, equitable and resilient agriculture systems... Read more...

Twin Tracks: Developing sustainably and equitably in a carbon-constrained world

How the Paris Agreement on Climate Change and the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development can complement and support each other towards a sustainable future

This report by CARE International and WWF International...

The resilience champions

When women contribute to the resilience of communities in the Sahel through savings and community-based adaptation

The main objective of this study, which was based on interviews with rural communities in Niger... Read more...